Skip to the main content

Demo

See each level of feedback on one draft

One essay, its brief and its marking criteria, read the way your own work would be. Open each tab in turn: the assignment, a Quick Grade, an Enhanced report, Deep feedback with the comments in the draft, then a second version.

This essay is invented. Nothing is saved and no credit is used. The student, the module and the brief were written for this page.

Essay · Second year of a bachelor's degree (Level 5) · APA, 7th edition

Should cities charge drivers to enter the centre?

Synthetic example

Predicted band · Version 1

Enhanced

Satisfactory to Good

A clearly organised essay with an arguable position, stated early. Its main weakness is evidence: one figure is asked to prove too much, and the fairness argument rests on an unsupported claim. The condition in your conclusion (spend the money on transport) is the most interesting idea, and the essay does not yet test it.

On the rubric's own bands. Confidence: medium. Argument and structure are at the Good descriptors; use of evidence and referencing are at Satisfactory, mostly because of the single source and the unsupported claim in paragraph 7.

The predicted band is an estimate from your criteria and your text. Only your institution awards marks.

An Enhanced review is a written report, and it downloads as a PDF. Your draft is not shown beside it: each comment says where in your draft it applies.

Strengths

  • A clear position in the opening paragraph.

    “a charge works when the money pays for better public transport”
  • Notices a second explanation for Singapore's result.

    “it is hard to say how much of the effect comes from the charge alone”
  • Headings follow the argument and are easy to follow.

    “Who pays”

Priorities

  1. Put the evidence in context. One figure from one city is asked to prove that the charge works. (Use of evidence)

  2. Support the fairness claim. "Everyone knows" stands in for evidence at the centre of the fairness section. (Argument)

  3. Test the condition in your conclusion. The essay never examines how either city spent the money it raised. (Argument)

Criterion by criterion

CriterionJudgementFrom your textWhat is missingNext step
Argument (30%)Meets“a charge works when the money pays for better public transport”The condition in the thesis is never tested against a real city.Examine how one city spent its charge income, and whether that made the charge fairer.
Use of evidence (30%)Partly meets“This shows the charge clearly worked.”Figures are used as proof without their limits; the fairness claim has no evidence.For each figure, say what it shows and what it cannot show.
Structure (20%)Meets“Who pays”The link between the fairness section and the thesis is left to the reader.End each section with a sentence that ties it back to your position.
Referencing (20%)Partly meets“Eliasson, J. (2009)”One source for several factual claims; APA formatting details.Find a source for each factual claim and check the APA format of the reference list.

Section by section

Introduction

States the problem and a two-part position in three sentences. The position is arguable, and the second half (fairness) sets up the later section well.

How a charge changes behaviour

Explains the mechanism clearly and brings in two cities, as the brief asks. The Stockholm paragraph draws a firmer conclusion than its one figure supports; the Singapore paragraph shows the caution the first one needs.

Who pays

Raises the right question for the fairness half of the position, but the central claim is asserted, not shown. The discounts paragraph introduces a trade-off and leaves it unconnected to the thesis.

Conclusion

Restates the position and adds the condition about spending the money. The condition is the essay's most interesting idea and is not tested anywhere before it.

Your actions

  1. A1. Put the Stockholm figure in context

    Criterion: Use of evidence. Effort: small. In your own feedback you can tick each action as you work.

  2. A2. Source the claim about Singapore's traffic speed

    Criterion: Referencing. Effort: small. In your own feedback you can tick each action as you work.

  3. A3. Support or narrow the claim about who keeps driving

    Criterion: Argument. Effort: medium. In your own feedback you can tick each action as you work.

  4. A4. Test your condition: how did one city spend the money?

    Criterion: Argument. Effort: large. In your own feedback you can tick each action as you work.

  5. A5. Check the APA format of the reference list

    Criterion: Referencing. Effort: small. In your own feedback you can tick each action as you work.

Facts and sources

In your draftCheckWhat to do
“traffic across the charging boundary fell by about a fifth in the first year (Eliasson, 2009)”CitedThe source is in your reference list. Check that the figure and the period match what it reports.
“Singapore has charged drivers since 1975”Needs a sourceA date stated as fact with no citation.
“Traffic in the centre moves faster than in many similar cities.”Needs a sourceA comparison with no source and no named cities.
“Everyone knows that rich people will just pay the fee and carry on driving.”UnsupportedA general claim presented as common knowledge.

Comments, located by section and paragraph

An Enhanced review has 8 to 12 comments. Each says where it applies and quotes the words it is about.

  1. C1 · Introduction, paragraph 2

    KeepLower priority
    “a charge works when the money pays for better public transport”

    A clear, arguable position in the first paragraph. The rest of the essay can be checked against it.

    Criterion: Argument

  2. C2 · How a charge changes behaviour, paragraph 4

    ReworkHigh priority
    “This shows the charge clearly worked.”

    One figure from one city cannot show that the charge worked in general. Say what the figure shows, and what else could explain the fall.

    Name one limit of the Stockholm figure, such as the time it covers or other changes that year.

    Criterion: Use of evidence

  3. C3 · How a charge changes behaviour, paragraph 5

    KeepLower priority
    “it is hard to say how much of the effect comes from the charge alone”

    Well spotted: you notice a second cause that could explain the result. This is the kind of caution the Stockholm paragraph needs too.

    Criterion: Use of evidence

  4. C4 · How a charge changes behaviour, paragraph 5

    EvidenceMedium priority
    “Traffic in the centre moves faster than in many similar cities.”

    This claim has no source. Which cities, measured how?

    Find a published comparison of average speeds and cite it in APA style.

    Criterion: Referencing

  5. C5 · Who pays, paragraph 7

    ReworkHigh priority
    “Everyone knows that rich people will just pay the fee and carry on driving.”

    "Everyone knows" is not evidence, and the claim is the centre of your fairness argument. Support it or narrow it.

    Look for a study of who kept driving after a charge was introduced, by income.

    Criterion: Argument

  6. C6 · Who pays, paragraph 8

    AddMedium priority
    “reduce the money it raises”

    This trade-off links back to your thesis about spending the money on transport. Make the link explicit.

    Criterion: Structure

  7. C7 · Conclusion, paragraph 10

    StructureMedium priority
    “It is fair only when the money improves buses and trains”

    The essay states this condition but never examines whether any city met it. The brief asks you to discuss two cities in depth.

    Add a section on how Stockholm or Singapore spent the money.

    Criterion: Argument

  8. C8 · References, paragraph 12

    ReferencingLower priority
    “Transportation Research Part A, 43(4), 468-480.”

    Only one source is listed, but the essay makes several factual claims. APA also asks for the journal title and volume in italics.

    Criterion: Referencing

Your own draft

Now read your own work this way

Create an account, upload your draft with its brief and criteria, and start with a Quick Grade. Every new account gets three free credits to spend on any level.

May we use Google Analytics to count visits and see which pages help people, so we can improve Gradevane? It sets cookies only if you accept, and never for advertising. The cookies the site needs to work are always on. Read the cookie notice.