Demo
See each level of feedback on one draft
One essay, its brief and its marking criteria, read the way your own work would be. Open each tab in turn: the assignment, a Quick Grade, an Enhanced report, Deep feedback with the comments in the draft, then a second version.
Essay · Second year of a bachelor's degree (Level 5) · APA, 7th edition
Should cities charge drivers to enter the centre?
Predicted band · Version 1
DeepSatisfactory to Good
A clearly organised essay with an arguable position, stated early. Its main weakness is evidence: one figure is asked to prove too much, and the fairness argument rests on an unsupported claim. The condition in your conclusion (spend the money on transport) is the most interesting idea, and the essay does not yet test it.
The predicted band is an estimate from your criteria and your text. Only your institution awards marks.
Strengths
A clear position in the opening paragraph.
“a charge works when the money pays for better public transport”
Notices a second explanation for Singapore's result.
“it is hard to say how much of the effect comes from the charge alone”
Headings follow the argument and are easy to follow.
“Who pays”
The conclusion sets a condition the whole argument can be tested against.
“It is fair only when the money improves buses and trains”
Priorities
Put the evidence in context. One figure from one city is asked to prove that the charge works. (Use of evidence)
Support the fairness claim. "Everyone knows" stands in for evidence at the centre of the fairness section. (Argument)
Test the condition in your conclusion. The essay never examines how either city spent the money it raised. (Argument)
Give each factual claim a source. Several claims rest on a single reference, and the list needs APA formatting. (Referencing)
A Deep review also has the criterion table, a report on each section, five actions and the checks on facts and sources, as in the Enhanced tab, and places its comments inside your draft.
The draft with comments
Each comment is tied to a phrase in the draft. Comments say what to change and why; none of them supplies a sentence to paste in. A Deep review places 15 to 25 comments in a draft; this short example shows 8.
Should cities charge drivers to enter the centre?
Many large cities face slow traffic, poor air and crowded streets. One answer is a congestion charge: a daily fee for driving into the centre. This essay argues that a charge works when the money pays for better public transport (comment C1: Keep), but that it can be unfair to people on low incomes who have no other way to travel.
C1KeepLower priority
On: “a charge works when the money pays for better public transport”
A clear, arguable position in the first paragraph. The rest of the essay can be checked against it.
Criterion: Argument
Back to the text
How a charge changes behaviour
The idea is simple. If driving costs more, some people will travel at another time, take a bus or not travel at all. Economists call this price elasticity. In Stockholm, traffic across the charging boundary fell by about a fifth in the first year (Eliasson, 2009). This shows the charge clearly worked (comment C2: Rework).
C2ReworkHigh priority
On: “This shows the charge clearly worked.”
One figure from one city cannot show that the charge worked in general. Say what the figure shows, and what else could explain the fall.
Pointer: Name one limit of the Stockholm figure, such as the time it covers or other changes that year.
Criterion: Use of evidence
Part of action A1
Back to the text
Singapore has charged drivers since 1975 and now uses electronic gantries that change the price by time of day. Traffic in the centre moves faster than in many similar cities (comment C4: Evidence). However, Singapore also limits how many cars can be bought, so it is hard to say how much of the effect comes from the charge alone (comment C3: Keep).
C3KeepLower priority
On: “it is hard to say how much of the effect comes from the charge alone”
Well spotted: you notice a second cause that could explain the result. This is the kind of caution the Stockholm paragraph needs too.
Criterion: Use of evidence
Back to the textC4EvidenceMedium priority
On: “Traffic in the centre moves faster than in many similar cities.”
This claim has no source. Which cities, measured how?
Pointer: Find a published comparison of average speeds and cite it in APA style.
Criterion: Referencing
Part of action A2
Back to the text
Who pays
Critics say a charge hits poorer drivers hardest. A nurse on a night shift may have no bus at that hour. Everyone knows that rich people will just pay the fee and carry on driving (comment C5: Rework).
C5ReworkHigh priority
On: “Everyone knows that rich people will just pay the fee and carry on driving.”
"Everyone knows" is not evidence, and the claim is the centre of your fairness argument. Support it or narrow it.
Pointer: Look for a study of who kept driving after a charge was introduced, by income.
Criterion: Argument
Part of action A3
Back to the text
Some cities give discounts to residents or to people with disabilities. These help, but they also make the scheme more complicated and reduce the money it raises (comment C6: Add).
C6AddMedium priority
On: “reduce the money it raises”
This trade-off links back to your thesis about spending the money on transport. Make the link explicit.
Criterion: Structure
Back to the text
Conclusion
In conclusion, a congestion charge can reduce traffic and pollution. It is fair only when the money improves buses and trains (comment C7: Structure), so that people who stop driving have a real choice.
C7StructureMedium priority
On: “It is fair only when the money improves buses and trains”
The essay states this condition but never examines whether any city met it. The brief asks you to discuss two cities in depth.
Pointer: Add a section on how Stockholm or Singapore spent the money.
Criterion: Argument
Part of action A4
Back to the text
References
Eliasson, J. (2009). A cost-benefit analysis of the Stockholm congestion charging system. Transportation Research Part A, 43(4), 468-480 (comment C8: Referencing).
C8ReferencingLower priority
On: “Transportation Research Part A, 43(4), 468-480.”
Only one source is listed, but the essay makes several factual claims. APA also asks for the journal title and volume in italics.
Criterion: Referencing
Part of action A5
Back to the text
Downloads
- The report, as a PDF or a Word document.
- Your draft with the comments in the margin, as a Word document. Your words are left as they were.
Both download from the result of a Deep review of your own draft; an Enhanced review downloads its report as a PDF. The example has nothing to download.
Your own draft
Now read your own work this way
Create an account, upload your draft with its brief and criteria, and start with a Quick Grade. Every new account gets three free credits to spend on any level.